Skip to Main content
  • Benny's Pizza

Benny's Pizza 18 West Road

18 West Road, Pleasant Valley, NY
‌
‌
Benny's Pizza
Two Pie Special!
Pasta Tuesdays!
Everyday Special!

Benny's Pizza

Appetizers

  • Beef Patty

    $3.99
  • Beef Patty w cheese

    $4.99
  • Boneless Wings

    $8.99+
  • Bread Sticks w Garlic (3)

    $4.99
  • Bread Sticks W Garlic & Cheese (3)

    $5.99
  • Broccoli Bites (8)

    $8.99
  • Calamari

    $13.99
  • Chicken Fingers

    $10.99
  • Chicken Fingers & Fries

    $13.99
  • French Fries

    $5.99
  • Garlic Bread

    $6.99
  • Garlic Bread w/ Cheese

    $7.99
  • Garlic Knot Slider - Chicken

    Crispy Chicken Cutlet, Mozzarella, Marinara Sauce in our house-made Garlic Knot Bun
    $5.99
  • Garlic Knot Slider - Meatball

    Meatball, Mozzarella, Marinara Sauce in our house-made Garlic Knot Bun
    $5.99
  • Garlic Knot Slider - Sausage & Pepper

    Sausage, Peppers, Onions, and Marinara Sauce in our house-made Garlic Knot Bun
    $5.99
  • Garlic Knots (6)

    $4.99
  • Garlic Knots w/ Cheese

    $5.99
  • Jalapeno Poppers (6)

    $9.99
  • Mac & Cheese Bites (8)

    $9.99
  • Mozzarella Sticks

    $9.99
  • Quesadilla - Chicken

    Chicken, Cheese, Peppers, Onions
    $13.99
  • Quesadilla - Steak

    Steak, Cheese, Peppers, Onions
    $14.99
  • Toasted Ravioli

    $9.99
  • Wings

    $8.99+

Salads

  • Antipasto Salad

    Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Cucumbers, Salami, Olives, Ham, Mozzarella
    $14.99
  • Caesar Salad

    Romaine Lettuce with Croutons
    $9.99
  • Chef Salad

    Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Cucumbers, Ham, Turkey & Mozzarella
    $13.99
  • Garden Salad

    Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Cucumbers, Carrots
    $8.99
  • Greek Salad

    Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Black Olives, and Feta Cheese
    $13.99
  • Side Salad

    A smaller portion of our Garden Salad. Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Cucumbers, Carrots
    $5.99

Soups

  • Chicken Noodle

    $7.99
  • Chili

    OUT OF STOCK
    $7.99
  • Pasta Fagioli

    $7.99
  • Veggie Chili

    $7.99

Pizza

  • Personal Pizza (12")

    $11.99
  • Small Pizza (14")

    $14.99
  • Large Pizza (16")

    $15.99
  • Sicilian

    $21.99
  • Gluten Free Pizza

    $14.99
  • Cauliflower

    $14.99

Pasta

  • Alfredo

    $17.99
  • Baked Ziti

    Marinara Sauce, Mozzarella & Ricotta
    $15.99
  • Cheese Ravioli

    $15.99
  • Eggplant Rollatini

    $19.99
  • Kids Pasta

    Small portion of pasta with butter or marinara sauce
    $7.99
  • Lasagna

    $18.99
  • Meat Sauce

    $15.99
  • Pasta Marinara

    $12.99
  • Pasta with Broccoli, Garlic & Oil

    $15.99
  • Pasta with Garlic & Oil

    $12.99
  • Penne Vodka

    $17.99
  • Spaghetti & Meatballs

    $15.99
  • Stuffed Shells

    $15.99

Entrees (served over pasta with a side salad & bread.)

  • Chicken Scarpariello

    Pan Seared Chicken, Sausage, Onion, Cherry Peppers & White Wine Sauce
    $23.99
  • Chicken Francese

    Lightly Battered Pan Fried Chicken Breast, Simmered over Buttery White Wine Lemon Sauce
    $22.99
  • Chicken Marsala

    Pan Seared Chicken, Sautéed Mushrooms & Marsala Wine
    $22.99
  • Parmigiana

    Chicken, Meatball, or Eggplant with Marinara Sauce & Mozzarella
    $21.99

Seafood Entrees

  • Linguini w Clam sauce

    Sautéed Clams with Garlic, Parsley, Olive Oil and Red or White Wine
    $22.99
  • Shrimp Francese

    Lightly Battered Pan Fried Shrimp, Simmered Over Buttery White Wine Lemon Sauce
    $23.99
  • Shrimp Parmigiana

    Shrimp, Marinara Sauce & Mozzarella
    $23.99
  • Shrimp Scampi

    Shrimp Sautéed in Garlic Butter & White Wine Sauce served over Pasta
    $23.99

Wraps

  • Buffalo Chicken Wrap

    Crispy Chicken Cutlet tossed in our House-made Buffalo Sauce, with Lettuce
    $12.99
  • Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap

    Crispy Chicken Cutlet, Bacon, Ranch with Lettuce
    $12.99
  • Chicken Wrap

    Crispy Chicken Cutlet, Lettuce, Tomatoes
    $12.99
  • Gjonis Wrap

    Crispy Chicken Cutlet, Penne Vodka, Mozzarella
    $13.99
  • Grilled Chicken Wrap

    Grilled Chicken, Lettuce, Tomatoes
    $12.99
  • Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap

    $12.99
  • Crispy Chicken Caesar Wrap

    $12.99
  • Turkey Wrap

    Turkey, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Mayo & American Cheese
    $12.99

Calzones

  • Cheese Calzone

    $8.99
  • Chicken Calzone

    $10.99
  • Ham Calzone

    $10.99
  • Pepperoni Calzone

    $10.99
  • Sausage Calzone

    $10.99
  • Spinach Calzone

    $10.99

Rolls/Pinwheels

  • Chicken Roll

    $9.99
  • Eggplant Roll

    $9.99
  • Ham Roll

    $9.99
  • Pepperoni Roll

    $9.99
  • Sausage & Peppers Roll

    $9.99
  • Spinach Roll

    $9.99
  • Stromboli

    Ham, Pepperoni, Salami
    $12.99
  • Pinwheels (3) - Chicken Parm

    $14.99
  • Pinwheels (3) - Vodka Chicken Parm

    $14.99
  • Pinwheels(3) - Buffalo Chicken

    $14.99
  • Pinwheels (3) - Chicken Bacon Ranch

    $14.99
  • Pinwheels (3) - Pepperoni & Hot Honey

    $14.99

Cold Sandwiches

  • Ham & Cheese Sandwich

    Ham, cheese, shredded lettuce, tomatoes & mayo
    $11.99
  • Italian Combo Sandwich

    Ham, salami, cheese, shredded lettuce, tomato, oil, vinegar
    $13.99
  • Salami & Cheese Sandwich

    Salami, cheese, shredded lettuce, tomatoes
    $11.99
  • Turkey & Cheese Sandwich

    Turkey cheese, shredded lettuce, tomatoes & mayo
    $11.99
  • American Combo

    Ham, Turkey, American Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo
    $13.99

Hot Sandwiches

  • The 914

    Chicken Cutlet. Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Red Peppers
    $13.99
  • Buffalo Jack Sandwich

    Crispy Chicken Cutlet, House-made Buffalo Sauce, Mozzarella
    $12.99
  • Chicken Club Sandwich

    Crispy Chicken Cutlet, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Mayo
    $12.99
  • Chicken Parm Sandwich

    Crispy Chicken Cutlet, Mozzarella, Marinara Sauce
    $12.99
  • Vodka Chicken Parm Sandwich

    Crispy Chicken Cutlet, Mozzarella, House-made Vodka Sauce
    $13.99
  • Eggplant Parm Sandwich

    Eggplant, Mozzarella, Marinara Sauce
    $12.99
  • Meatball Parm Sandwich

    Meatballs, Mozzarella, Marinara Sauce
    $12.99
  • Pepper & Eggs Wedge

    $9.99
  • Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich

    Chopped Steak w/ Peppers, Onions, American Cheese
    $13.99
  • Sausage & Peppers Sandwich

    w/ Onions & Marinara Sauce
    $12.99
  • Sausage Parm Sandwich

    Sausage, Mozzarella, Marinara Sauce
    $12.99
  • Shrimp Parmigiana Sandwich

    Shrimp, Mozzarella, Marinara Sauce
    $13.99
  • Chicken Francese Sandwich

    $13.99

Side Order

  • Broccoli Garlic & Oil

    $6.99
  • Side Meatballs

    $6.99
  • Side Sausage

    $6.99
  • Spinach Garlic & Oil

    $6.99
  • Side of Grilled Chicken

    $6.99
  • Side of Chicken Cutlet (Breaded)

    $6.99

Desserts

  • Cannoli

    $4.99
  • Cheesecake

    $5.99
  • Tiramisu

    $5.99
  • Zeppoli

    $5.99

Slices

  • Plain Slice

    $4.00
  • Specialty Slice

    $4.50

Drinks

  • 2 Liter

    $4.25
  • 20 oz

    $2.75
  • Cans

    $1.85
  • Sports Drinks

    $3.50
  • Gold Peak

    $3.50
  • Water

    $2.00
  • Az

    $1.00
  • Starbucks Frapp

    $3.75

Catering

  • 40 Pieces

    BBQ, Mild, Hot, or Extra Hot
    $65.00
  • 80 Pieces

    BBQ, Mild, Hot, or Extra Hot
    $110.00
  • Alfredo

    Must order in person
    $55.00+
  • American Combo - $23/ft

    Must order in person
    $69.00+
  • Antipasto Salad

    Must order in person
    $55.00+
  • Baked Ziti

    $50.00+
  • Caesar Salad

    Must order in person
    $40.00+
  • Cheese Raviolli

    Must order in person
    $50.00+
  • Chicken Cutlet - $25/ft

    Must order in person
    $75.00+
  • Chicken Francese

    Must order in person
    $65.00+
  • Chicken Marsala

    Must order in person
    $65.00+
  • Chicken Parmigiana

    Must order in person
    $65.00+
  • Chicken Scarpariello

    Must order in person
    $70.00+
  • Chicken Tenders

    Must order in person
    $55.00+
  • Eggplant Parmigiana

    Must order in person
    $65.00+
  • Eggplant Rollatini

    Must order in person
    $65.00+
  • Garden Salad

    Must order in person
    $40.00+
  • Garlic Knots

    Must order in person
    $35.00+
  • Greek Salad

    Must order in person
    $55.00+
  • Italian Combo - $23/ft

    Must order in person
    $69.00+
  • Lasagna

    Must order in person
    $60.00+
  • Meatball Parmigiana

    Must order in person
    $65.00+
  • Meatballs

    $60.00+
  • Mozzarella Sticks

    Must order in person
    $55.00+
  • Pasta Marinara

    Must order in person
    $45.00+
  • Pasta with Broccoli Garlic & Oil

    Must order in person
    $50.00+
  • Pasta with Garlic & Oil

    Must order in person
    $45.00+
  • Penne Vodka

    Must order in person
    $55.00+
  • Sausage & Peppers

    Must order in person
    $60.00+
  • Stuffed Shells

    Must order in person
    $50.00+

Paninis

  • The Capri Press

    Grilled Chicken, Fresh Mozzarella, Tomato, Garlic, Pesto Sauce, served w/ fries
    $15.99
  • The Adriatic

    Eggplant, Tomato, Fresh Mozzarella, Basil, Balsamic Glaze, served w/ fries
    $15.99
  • The Southwest Smoke

    Roasted Turkey, Cheddar Cheese, Cajun Spice, Chipotle Mayo, served w/ fries
    $15.99
  • The Backyard Melt

    Chicken Cutlet, Bacon, Cheddar Cheese, Ranch, served w/ fries
    $15.99
  • The Sweet Heat

    Chicken Cutlet, Jalapenos, American Cheese, Hot Honey, Chipotle Mayo, served w/ fries
    $15.99

Two Pie Special!

Two Pie Special

  • 2 Small Cheese Pies

    $25.99

Pasta Tuesdays!

You Pick 2 Pastas!

  • Pasta Tuesday!

    $24.99

Everyday Special!

  • Large Cheese Pie, Penne Vodka, Garlic Knots

    $30.99

Spinach Roll

$9.99

Customize your item

Extra Roll Sauce

Optional
1

Benny's Pizza Location and Hours

(845) 723-4482
18 West Road, Pleasant Valley, NY 12569
Open now • Closes at 8:59PM
View menu
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement