Skip to Main content
Benny's Pizza
0
Order Online
Sign in
Home
/
Sicilian
Sicilian
$0
Cook Type
Required
Select 1
Light Cooked
Regular Cook
Well Done
Pizza Toppings
Optional
Cheese
Extra Cheese
+$3.50
Basil
+$3.50
Black Olives
+$3.50
Broccoli
+$3.00
Chicken Cutlet
+$3.50
Eggplant
+$3.00
Garlic
+$3.50
Green Peppers
+$3.50
Ham
+$3.50
Jalapenos
+$3.50
Meatball
+$3.50
Mushrooms
+$3.50
Onions
+$3.50
Pepperoni
+$3.50
Pineapple
+$3.50
Red Peppers
+$3.50
Ricotta
+$3.00
Sausage
+$3.50
Spinach
+$3.50
Tomato
+$3.50
Bacon
+$3.00
Large Left Half
Optional
Cheese
Left Extra Cheese
+$2.50
Left Bacon
+$2.50
Left Basil
+$2.50
Left Black Olives
+$2.50
Left Broccoli
+$2.50
Left Chicken Cutlet
+$2.50
Left Eggplant
+$2.50
Left Garlic
+$2.50
Left Green Peppers
+$2.50
Left Ham
+$2.50
Left Jalapenos
+$2.50
Left Meatball
+$2.50
Left Mushrooms
+$2.50
Left Onions
+$2.50
Left Pepperoni
+$2.50
Left Pineapple
+$2.50
Left Red Peppers
+$2.50
Left Ricotta
+$2.50
Left Sausage
+$2.50
Left Spinach
+$2.50
Left Tomato
+$2.50
Large Right Half
Optional
Cheese
Right Extra Cheese
+$2.50
Right Bacon
+$2.50
Right Basil
+$2.50
Right Black Olives
+$2.50
Right Broccoli
+$2.50
Right Chicken Cutlet
+$2.50
Right Garlic
+$2.50
Right Eggplant
+$2.50
Right Green Peppers
+$2.50
Right Ham
+$2.50
Right Jalapenos
+$2.50
Right Meatball
+$2.50
Right Mushrooms
+$2.50
Right Onions
+$2.50
Right Pepperoni
+$2.50
Right Pineapple
+$2.50
Right Red Peppers
+$2.50
Right Ricotta
+$2.50
Right Sausage
+$2.50
Right Spinach
+$2.50
Right Tomato
+$2.50
Sicilian Specialty Left Half
Select up to 1
Left BBQ Chicken
+$2.00
Left Buffalo Chicken
+$2.00
Left Chicken Bacon Ranch
+$3.00
Left Chicken Parm Pizza
+$3.00
Left Hawaiian
+$3.00
Left Hot Pie
+$3.00
Left Meat Lover's
+$4.00
Left The Classic Pie
+$4.00
Sicilian Specialty Right Half
Select up to 1
Right BBQ Chicken
+$2.00
Right Buffalo Chicken
+$2.00
Right Chicken Bacon Ranch
+$3.00
Right Chicken Parm Pizza
+$3.00
Right Hawaiian
+$3.00
Right Hot Pie
+$3.00
Right Meat Lover's
+$4.00
Right The Classic Pie
+$4.00
Sicilian Specialty
Select up to 1
BBQ Chicken
+$2.00
Benny's Pie
+$3.00
Buffalo Chicken
+$2.00
Chicken Bacon Ranch
+$6.00
Chicken Parm Pizza
+$6.00
Drunk Grandmas
+$3.00
Drunk Grandma Hot Honey Pepperoni
+$3.00
Grandma's Pizza
+$1.00
Hawaiian
+$6.00
Hot Pie
+$6.00
Jozef's Pie
+$1.00
Meat Lover's
+$6.00
Penne Vodka Pizza
+$6.00
Philly Cheesesteak Pizza
+$6.00
The Classic Pie
+$6.00
Tri Color Pie
+$6.00
Add to Cart
1
Benny's Pizza Location and Hours
(845) 723-4482
18 West Road, Pleasant Valley, NY 12569
Open now
•
Closes at 8:59PM
All hours
View menu
Terms of Service
|
Privacy Statement
